American First Team
| Jaime Gaal | Quarterback | St. Louis SLAM |
| Brittany Mayer | Quarterback | Nebraska Pride |
| Jesse Felker | Quarterback | Nevada Storm |
| Sarah Teubner | Quarterback | Capital Pioneers |
| Erin Kelley | Quarterback | Minnesota Vixen |
| Kerri McMahan | Wide Receiver | St. Louis SLAM |
| Sydney Bloch | Wide Receiver | St. Louis SLAM |
| Desiree Jeffries | Wide Receiver | OKC Lady Force |
| Jackie Radford | Wide Receiver | Minnesota Vixen |
| Nicole Skolnick | Wide Receiver | Nebraska Pride |
| Hannah Anderson | Wide Receiver | Nevada Storm |
| Savannah Burkhalter | Wide Receiver | Dallas ELITE Mustangs |
| Jodi Lindemann | Wide Receiver | Capital Pioneers |
| Brianna Barrett | Wide Receiver | Cali War |
| Jada Humphrey | Tailback | St. Louis SLAM |
| Tamira Sweet | Tailback | OKC Lady Force |
| Sarah Rosche | Tailback | Minnesota Vixen |
| Johanna Vermohlen | Tailback | Minnesota Vixen |
| Tiffany Wright | Tailback | Nebraska Pride |
| Brook Wilson | Tailback | Houston Energy |
| Wyshana Brooks | Tailback | New Mexico Banitas |
| Smash Watson | Tailback | Rocky Mountain Thunderkatz |
| Priscilla Gardner | Tailback | Cali War |
| Mary Ramos | Tailback | Mile High Blaze |
| Kara Haines | Fullback | OKC Lady Force |
| Suzette Garrett | Fullback | Houston Energy |
| Angela Brazil-Menard | Tight End | Nebraska Pride |
| Dez Seastrunk | Tight End | Dallas ELITE Mustangs |
| Tamikka Brents | Offensive Line | St. Louis SLAM |
| Leah Knighton | Offensive Line | OKC Lady Force |
| Sami Krause | Offensive Line | Minnesota Vixen |
| Jessica Rivas | Offensive Line | Houston Energy |
| Carrie Mackey | Offensive Line | Nevada Storm |
| Kara Lagafuaiana | Offensive Line | Az Outkast |
| Kailey Hunt | Offensive Line | Austin Outlaws |
| Ollie Herbert | Offensive Line | Oregon |
| Courtney Gibson-Thomas | Offensive Line | Minnesota Minx |
| Jasmine Alequin | Offensive Line | Mile High Blaze |
| Erica Williams | Offensive Line | Zydeco Spice |
| Caitlin Erickson | Center | St. Louis SLAM |
| Charlie Barba-Cook | Center | Minnesota Vixen |
| Rebecca Romero | Center | Austin Outlaws |
| Francine Loya | Center | Cali War |
| Alisha Straws | Linebacker | St. Louis SLAM |
| Mary Altepeter | Linebacker | St. Louis SLAM |
| Sade Roberts | Linebacker | OKC Lady Force |
| Britta Clark | Linebacker | Minnesota Vixen |
| Niesha Washington | Linebacker | Nevada Storm |
| Shannon Delarosbil | Linebacker | New Mexico Banitas |
| Sareli Utley | Linebacker | Az Outkast |
| Carissa Marler | Linebacker | Sioux falls Snow Leopards |
| Suzanne Linn | Linebacker | Cali War |
| Leilani Caamal | Linebacker | Mile High Blaze |
| Clarissa Adams | Linebacker | Capital Pioneers |
| Megan Hart | Linebacker | Mile High Blaze |
| Taylor Johnson | Defensive Tackle | St. Louis SLAM |
| Heather Dorsey | Defensive Tackle | OKC Lady Force |
| Samira Garcia Pedro | Defensive Tackle | Minnesota Vixen |
| Datiana Sikahema | Defensive Tackle | Houston Energy |
| Hadiisha Butts | Defensive Tackle | Dallas ELITE Mustangs |
| Antoinette Borders-Frazier | Defensive Tackle | Cali War |
| Shauntavia Brigham | Defensive Tackle | Mile High Blaze |
| Bianca Clues | Defensive Tackle | Zydeco Spice |
| Myah LeFlore | Defensive End | St. Louis SLAM |
| Shabria Irby | Defensive End | OKC Lady Force |
| Kim Rose | Defensive End | Dallas ELITE Mustangs |
| Shy Armstrong | Defensive End | Rocky Mountain Thunderkatz |
| Jasmine Crisp | Defensive End | Oklahoma Rage |
| Marchinee Lewis | Defensive End | Cali War |
| Jamie Robinson | Defensive End | Cali War |
| Tamara Taylor | Defensive End | Mile High Blaze |
| Priscilla Garcia | Defensive End | Mile High Blaze |
| Kyia Quinones | Cornerback | OKC Lady Force |
| Jasmine Guys | Cornerback | OKC Lady Force |
| Caitlin Hill | Cornerback | Minnesota Vixen |
| Alyssa Williams | Cornerback | Nevada Storm |
| Alex Jackson | Cornerback | Dallas ELITE Mustangs |
| Sonfre Roberson | Cornerback | Cali War |
| Sam Barber | Strong Safety | Minnesota Vixen |
| Kelsey West | Strong Safety | Houston Energy |
| Leandre Smith | Strong Safety | Cali War |
| Britt Peterson | Free Safety | Nebraska Pride |
| Dani Spearman | Free Safety | Houston Energy |
| Isabel Flores | Free Safety | Central Valley Chaos |
| Melanie Archuleta | Kicker | Mile High Blaze |
| JB Goodlow | Kick Returner | Az Outkast |
| Reese Peterson | Kick Returner | Mile High Blaze |
National First Team
| Marcelina Chavez | Quarterback | Pittsburgh Passion |
| Madison Frazer | Quarterback | Atlanta Rage |
| Amanda Congialdi | Quarterback | D.C. Divas |
| Angela Mason | Quarterback | Cincinnati Cougars |
| Jana Meister | Wide Receiver | Pittsburgh Passion |
| Stephanie Pascual | Wide Receiver | Boston Renegades |
| Adrienne Smith | Wide Receiver | Boston Renegades |
| Shaquanda Gainey | Wide Receiver | D.C. Divas |
| Kristie Kelly | Wide Receiver | D.C. Divas |
| Meg Joyce | Wide Receiver | Tampa Bay Inferno |
| Destiny Nelson | Wide Receiver | Alabama Fire |
| Katelyn Cox | Wide Receiver | East Tennessee Valkyrie |
| Gina Capardi | Wide Receiver | New York Wolves |
| Dana Blakey | Wide Receiver | D.C. Divas |
| Devon Peace | Tailback | Pittsburgh Passion |
| Kiana Williams | Tailback | Cincinnati Cougars |
| Juliette Turner | Tailback | Tampa Bay Inferno |
| Clarissa Tullis | Tailback | Detroit Venom |
| Essence Buckner | Tailback | Derby City Dynamite |
| Lasondrya Williams | Fullback | West Palm Beach Coyotes |
| Tynequia Roberts | Fullback | Tampa Bay Inferno |
| Regine Turner | Tight End | West Palm Beach Coyotes |
| Jess Hayden | Offensive Line | Boston Renegades |
| Janvier Harper | Offensive Line | Atlanta Rage |
| Dumatra McDaniel | Offensive Line | Atlanta Rage |
| Anni Alanko | Offensive Line | D.C. Divas |
| Delores Elliott | Offensive Line | D.C. Divas |
| Kelsea Meyer | Offensive Line | NY Knockout |
| Alexis Walker | Offensive Line | Tampa Bay Inferno |
| Tamaira Crews | Offensive Line | Tampa Bay Inferno |
| Charity Gilbert | Offensive Line | Baltimore Nighthawks |
| Monica Southall | Offensive Line | Virginia Panthers |
| Kimberly Thomas | Offensive Line | Alabama Fire |
| Lena Tankeng | Offensive Line | New York Wolves |
| Juile Day | Offensive Line | Columbus Chaos |
| Pertrice Stewart-Lane | Offensive Line | Music city mizfits |
| Kylie Roebuck | Center | Pittsburgh Passion |
| Kristin Nicholson | Center | Tampa Bay Inferno |
| Thelma Banks | Center | Derby City Dynamite |
| Katelyn Polenik | Linebacker | Pittsburgh Passion |
| Solina Pascual | Linebacker | Boston Renegades |
| Darcy Leslie | Linebacker | Boston Renegades |
| Twinesha Clay | Linebacker | Atlanta Rage |
| Essi Saastamoinen | Linebacker | D.C. Divas |
| Carrie Hall | Linebacker | D.C. Divas |
| Ashleigh Sellick | Linebacker | NY Knockout |
| Roberta Pass | Linebacker | Tampa Bay Inferno |
| Emily D'Ascenzo | Linebacker | Detroit Venom |
| Rashida Ford | Linebacker | Baltimore Nighthawks |
| Alicia Meyer | Linebacker | Derby City Dynamite |
| Kara Gailiunas | Linebacker | Boston Renegades |
| Kaitlyn Niedermeyer | Defensive Tackle | Pittsburgh Passion |
| Jazmine Correa | Defensive Tackle | Tampa Bay Inferno |
| Tiki Malone- | Defensive Tackle | Detroit Venom |
| Angelita Furman | Defensive Tackle | Derby City Dynamite |
| Ta’Naja Bostic | Defensive Tackle | Connecticut Ambush |
| Dateasha Barbour | Defensive Tackle | East Tennessee Valkyrie |
| Bobbie Goodwin | Defensive Tackle | Grand Rapids Tidal Waves |
| Kim Zubovic | Defensive End | Pittsburgh Passion |
| Danielle Fournier | Defensive End | Boston Renegades |
| Daitanah Smith | Defensive End | Boston Renegades |
| Shatonya Spicer | Defensive End | Atlanta Rage |
| Gabrielle Fleming | Defensive End | D.C. Divas |
| Mariah Turner | Defensive End | Tampa Bay Inferno |
| Brooke Little | Defensive End | Derby City Dynamite |
| Natasha Butts | Defensive End | Virginia Panthers |
| Waynicia Thomas | Defensive End | Alabama Fire |
| Asia Strickland | Defensive End | New York Wolves |
| Michelle Robinson | Defensive End | Jacksonville Dixie Blues |
| Sebria Douse | Cornerback | Atlanta Rage |
| Kucheria Johnson | Cornerback | D.C. Divas |
| Amiyah Baker | Cornerback | Tampa Bay Inferno |
| Destinee Russell | Cornerback | Detroit Venom |
| Cherelle Allen | Cornerback | Connecticut Ambush |
| Nhandi Brown | Cornerback | New York Wolves |
| Katie Salisbury | Strong Safety | NY Knockout |
| Gianna Charest | Strong Safety | Maine Mayhem |
| Catrina Fincher | Strong Safety | Alabama Fire |
| Katelynne Grunza | Strong Safety | Columbus Chaos |
| Danasha Harris | Free Safety | Pittsburgh Passion |
| Kaci Cunningham | Free Safety | Detroit Venom |
| Breonna Brewer | Free Safety | Baltimore Nighthawks |
| Kodie Johnson | Kicker | Pittsburgh Passion |
| Kate McEachern | Kicker | Columbus Chaos |
| Shani Dummott | Kick Returner | Boston Renegades |
| Daundrianique Greenland | Kick Returner | West Palm Beach Coyotes |
| Kylee O'Connor-Harrel | Punt Returner | Boston Renegades |